Archive for the 'Home Electronics&Entertainment' Category


The State of Media Player

Home entertainment is in the midst of a transformation that may give consumers the ability to truly watch and listen to what they want when they want. I am, of course, describing the media center appliance, an appliance-like unit that marries to one’s home entertainment system and allows for multimedia content from various sources (traditional cable, home file server via TCP/IP network, VCR, DVD etc) to be utilized as the user chooses. These media players have been around in one form or another since VGA ports started commonly appearing on the back of TV sets over almost a decade ago. The problem has been two-fold: the UI (user interface) and the content control.

User interface design (or HCI) is a study of reducing and simplifying the number of visual cues required for humans to quickly and easily accomplish computer-based tasking. Without going into great description, it would suffice to say that the efforts the market has seen so far have been mediocre, at best. Too often (as in Microsoft’s “Media Center” and “Home Server” products) the products introduced are nothing more than sophomoric regurgitations of existing products (MS Media Center used a re-factored XP) — often performing some of the key features of a media appliance as though it were a “bolt-on” or an after-thought.

Media control is likely the largest factor in the glacial pace that the innovation of the media appliance has taken. Media rights groups (MPAA, RIAA, etc) feel a concern that copyrighted and trademarked materials will be abused if the media player mfgs are not compelled to design equipment that respects the digital rights of media creators. The reality is these greedy media pigs are probably more of an impediment to a meaningful solution than any sort of catalyst. There is no doubt digital rights need to be preserved, however, at a time when we are seeing intellectual property in other realms (i.e., pharma, bio, medicine, agri, etc) be afforded shorter windows of exclusivity it would seem daft and out-of-step not to see similar considerations made on multimedia properties as well.

Presently, I am using an AppleTV, a stripped down PC and a Sonos unit (ZP120) and I like them all. That said, I wish I could have the features each has in one box/appliance. The AppleTV works well for me however, the fact it will play only Quicktime MOV, MP3 and M4V make it less than a complete solution. Apple stupidly made iTunes the “sync-n-add” mechanism for the AppleTV rather than having the Apple TV unit operate with a web interface on-board to manage these all load and organize tasks. This was an odd mistake for Apple – only further demonstrating that even those with good track records in providing consumer electronics have not had a winner here yet.

The Sonos is a real winner and – if it had a means to offer video as well – would likely be my choice. However, it does not — leaving the product a good match only for my sound (not visual) needs.

The stripped down PC is by far the most useful but the least easy to use. The keyboard and mouse ( is clunky and a piss-poor match for the needs one has in a home entertainment landscape.  No matter – sometimes you have to do what you have to do.

BTW, if any of you have good things to say about any and all media server/centers please feel free to embellish in comments.  I would love to get some insights from others on this topic.


Moments - powered by Flickr

RSS Economy – Powered by BookMach

  • An error has occurred; the feed is probably down. Try again later.

RSS MarketPulse

  • Yi Gang, U.S.-trained economist, to lead China's central bank March 19, 2018
    Yi Gang, a U.S.-trained economist, will lead the People's Bank of China, replacing longtime governor Zhou Xiaochuan. Yi's appointment was approved Monday by the National People's Congress. Zhou led China's central bank for 15 years. Yi, 60, has a Ph.D. from the University of Illinois and taught at the University of Indiana. He is a vetera […]
  • Another explosion injures 2 men in Austin, Texas March 19, 2018
    Two people were injured by an explosion Sunday night in Austin, Texas, following three package bombs that killed two people and injured two others earlier this month. Officials didn't immediately give the cause of the explosion. Austin-Travis County Emergency Management Services tweeted that two men in their 20s had been hospitalized with non-life-threa […]
  • Trump required White House staffers to sign NDAs: report March 18, 2018
    President Donald Trump required White House staff members to sign nondisclosure agreements, the Washington Post reported Sunday, that threatened stiff financial penalties and extended past Trump's time in office. Post columnist Ruth Marcus reported that many aides were reluctant to sign, but were pressured to by then-Chief of Staff Reince Priebus and th […]
  • Facebook suspends data firm tied to Trump campaign March 17, 2018
    Facebook said late Friday that it has suspended Cambridge Analytica, a data firm best known for its role in the presidential campaign of Donald Trump, and parent firm Strategic Communication Laboratories for policy violations. In a statement, the social-media company said Cambridge Analytica had come into possession of, against Facebook policies, personal da […]